If your answer is no, then at what point does it stop being the same ship? Once the first plank is replaced? The last? Halfway through?
If your answer is yes, then why? If the ship had been taken apart and put back together with completely different pieces all at once, then would it still be the same ship? Or does it only apply when the change is gradual?
Now, consider this:
Cells in your body do the same thing the planks do. They die out, and they're replaced. After about seven years, each cell in your body has been replaced and none of the original cells remain.
Are you still the same person? If so, why?
The way that I think about it, the ship is not the same ship because the ship doesn't have memories or a brain. But you are still the same person because you still have all your memories that you accumulated throughout your life, and still the same personality. however, I'm not sure when exactly the ship stops being the same ship...... that's a tough question haha
ReplyDelete